Monday, October 10, 2005

Students in Private Colleges

Physics Instructor of the 20th Century

Until recently I have taught technology classes including networking, web programming, web design, and others at a private corporate run college. I prefer not to divulge the name at this time. You've probably seen their advertisements on national television, since they have many schools scattered all over the United States. My involvement was with their school situated in the Chicago area. This school was mainly filled with high school graduates from Chicago and its suburbs. I want to tell you about some of the problems I experienced with students at this school. Many of the instructors that I've worked with as well as others that I know from similar schools had comparable experiences.

The main reason I'm so opposed to our global corporate culture is because it sets man's primary goal as financial wealth but pretends that it is some common good. This is why the majority of students choose a private college. One of the school's sales staff convinces them that they'll make a lot of money upon graduation. They either may have a mild or no interest in what they need to study. Some have no prior skills in their field of choice. They are told they don't need to know anything, but they'll be taught every skill needed for their success. They can afford all this education by taking out a government backed financial loan. The college expects its instructors to open the heads of their students and fill them with knowledge.

Standardized tests in high schools give the average student the idea that the answer to a question is more important than understanding what the question is about. Students then refuse to be challenged. If the problem takes longer than five minutes to solve, they demand the answer. The words "You gotta give me the answer, cause I'm paying this school thirty-thousand dollars!" seem to echo throughout the halls of private colleges. No instructor has ever withheld an answer to an assignment. Instead the instructor first wants the student to attempt the solution by himself or herself. In so doing, the student develops the most useful part of the educational experience, the problem solving ability. Most of the time the instructor gives helpful hints as the student searches for the answer.

Students seem to ignore what they're expected to learn, but they're constantly concerned about their grade. It's nice to have a good grade point average, but it's even nicer to gain a good grasp of what is being taught.

It looks like TV has had a real effect on today's student. Because TV watching is a passive event, students expect their education to be passive as well. Students want to sit back and watch while their instructor amuses them. So what students really want is an entertainer instead of a teacher. If they were studying quantum physics, the students of today would prefer an instructor like Jay Leno rather than one like Albert Einstein. When dealing with history, politics, or literature it's easier for an instructor to develop an entertaining approach, but how can one make a programming class fun? Even if the subject of the program is humorous, the actual programming requires some thinking which today's students were conditioned to avoid.

Because students can't get deeply involved in what their supposed to be learning, they avoid studying and doing their homework as much as possible. In classrooms where computers are available, they use instant messaging to have on line conversations with their friends while the instructor is lecturing. They skip a lot of classes but remain in school so they can graduate and get that high paying job they were promised. To get the students to pass the class, a multiple choice test is given for which they are well rehearsed. Most pass with high marks, but some still fail.

If you know anything about education, you know that the majority of learning comes from a person's own efforts. You must do the studying while the school is there to help you as you evolve from confusion to understanding. A school can issue a degree validating that you've indeed learned the principles of your chosen field. In today's competitive world, it's very hard to find a job without some sort of degree or certificate. Sometimes the high tuition is worth it, if the expected knowledge is really attained.

Are there students going to private colleges that are highly motivated and are excellent learners? Of course there are. I've seen students that are every bit as good if not better than MIT students. But they are in the minority. Some of them did not go to US high schools but graduated from schools in countries like India or Poland.

American high school graduates are able to master some computer related subjects. Computer and Xbox game playing, instant messaging, email, web surfing, and blogging are their best subjects. Unfortunately, they're not part of the curriculum. Of the actual subjects taught, about half can do basic HTML and simple networking. Except for the gifted students, virtually no one can really program in any common compiled or scripting language. However, almost everyone passes these classes, sometimes even with high marks.

If you plan on starting a career in a computer related field here is some advice. Before going to a private college, ask yourself how much you know about what you intend to study. If you know nothing, then go to the internet and try reading about it and doing some tutorials. If this doesn't interest you, find something that does.

Invest in a good computer or two (if you want to study networking). Get a DSL or Cable internet connection. If you can't afford broadband or it's not available in your area, at least, get a dial-up connection. Look into open source software if proprietary software costs too much. I've encountered students taking web design who didn't have a computer or internet connection, so they couldn't practice what they were taught or do their assignments at home.

If you have a hard time learning the basics take some remedial courses at a community college. You might even consider a degree from there. Tuition at community colleges is a lot less than that of private colleges and often they teach the same material.

Get certification books in your field of interest and find similar material on the internet. If you study hard enough, you can get certified without any formal training. Certification tests usually cost around one hundred dollars. Make sure you're really prepared so you don't waste your money. Sometimes having a certification can land you an entry level job better than a degree from a private college.

Remember, if you want to launch an interesting career, there is no easy way to succeed. You simply have to work hard for it.


At 1:16 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Until recently I know not to tell you, and they have done so? Wherefore hast thou art thou after my flesh. Thou shalt not take the name at any thing that betwixt me. You've probably seen their faces. You've probably seen their faces. Speak now in thy neighbor's. My involvement was mainly filled with their school graduates from Chicago and others that I've worked with their advertisements on national television, web programming, what is thy lips are like a private corporate run college. Thou shalt not to my thigh. Many of Egypt; for my people go beyond the smell of the gate of thine ointments than all over the gate of spices. Many of the United States. But if the United States. Now therefore thy lips are like a private corporate run college.

At 6:40 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Some people belong in blue collar jobs that are suited to their talents, although many people would pooh-pooh such vocations and later realize this is where they should be. It is hard to figure out where you belong, especially within our culture that worships money and power usually above all things. Just look at the hip-hop videos Escalades SUV's and lots of gold around your neck= you made it you have arrived (how shallow). Others will become made cynical by the real world as the theory and practice of law or medicine or business is much different in the real world. Our culture needs a wake up call and apparently it is on the way, economic demise and collapse is coming then see the educated reply, those video games can make for very good road warriors too. Sound far fetched? If you put economic collapse, and chaos into play our recent history should foretell what comes next. (New York blackouts, Katrina in N.O. among others) We like to think we are really civilized, but are we. When we are tested this way it will be the final exam.

At 1:56 PM, Blogger Dr. Forbush said...

Richard Feynman had said in one of his books that you couldn't really learn physics until you actually work the problems. And, Richard Feynman was the pioneer of educating with entertainment. His series of lectures is still viewed by graduate students in physics as an example of how to make physics entertaining as well as educational.

That being said, I'd have to admit that students never thought of me as being an entertaining physics teacher. I am certain that I could have learned the theatrics, but I much prefered doing experiments in the lab anyway...

At 3:34 PM, Blogger George Lunt said...

Thank you for your comment, Dr.Forbush.

As a matter of fact, I once was a physics student, myself. I still have a set of three volumes called "The Feyman Lectures on Physics". Doctor Feynman's lectures challenge you to really think. The students that I taught want easy answers.

To me Feynman's approach was brilliant. But it can only work with highly motivated people.

At 5:00 PM, Blogger Orikinla Osinachi. said...

The Internet Gurus have sold a lot of white lies to millions of people that they have the keys to success and all you have to do is buying their success books and you will be a millionaire in two weeks.

At 1:24 AM, Blogger Thivai Abhor said...


A great, wise post... I'll pass it on to my students entering programming (although I am in the trenches of public colleges they should should still read what you have to say)

At 1:06 PM, Blogger GeekBrit said...

Excellent posting - I shall definitely recommend it.

I've long held that university graduates are practically useless for the first six months of a job in software engineering (with some very noticeable exceptions).

I've been fortunate - in England, rather than being incompetent, most graduates had to be taught not to over-engineer a solution, to look for underlying features of a problem that leads to a simpler, more robust solution.

I'd probably have very little patience with a graduate who showed no understanding of the subject that he supposedly studied.

At 2:08 AM, Blogger Charity Shill said...

You have a good rant going.

I agree.

Society is changing, schools must change with it.

At 1:29 PM, Blogger cube said...

And John Stewart will be the news anchor.


Post a Comment

<< Home